Review: Jack Barentsen, “Emerging Leadership in the Pauline Mission: A Social Identity Perspective on Local Leadership Development in Corinth and Ephesus”

Emerging Leadership in the Pauline Mission Thank you to Pickwick for the review copy.

Whether you are a theologian or a biblical scholar, this book deserves a read. Jack Barentsen applies social identity theory to a study of the Christ-following communities in Corinth and Ephesus. Viewing Paul’s letters as “instruments of leadership,” Barentsen examines Pauline leadership emergence, maintenance, and succession in these two locations, as Paul shapes their identity as Christ-followers. The social identity model of leadership integrates the social (historical) and psychological (ideological) factors shaping Paul’s correspondence, providing a heuristic model which can get at the “how” and “why” of Pauline leadership patterns, as opposed to simply their content. Social identity theory can be particularly helpful in assisting more individualistic, global North Christ-followers to understand the cultural world within which Paul and the early Christ-followers lived. Barentsen then explains specifically how Paul assisted the Christ-following community to see their membership in Christ as their superordinate identity.

Also, having a more fleshed-out picture of the early church’s background allows Barentsen to make sense of seemingly inconsistent aspects of Paul. For example, why is it that sometimes Paul emphasizes his own apostolic authority (at the expense of local leaders), while other times he downplays his role and empowers local leaders? The social identity theory of leadership also allows Barentsen to challenge – successfully – the Holzmann-Sohm hypothesis, which suggests that early church leadership was originally charismatic, then later became legalistic and focused upon offices. Wrapping up his work with avenues for further study and implications of his work, Barentsen makes his own suggestion as to what aspect(s) of Pauline leadership are cross-cultural.

This is an exciting study for people interested in Pauline theology, leadership strategies past and present, church government, application of social identity theory to biblical studies, as well as methods for historical study of the NT that neither exclude nor marginalize theology. I hope to see more of this sort of work!


About Stephanie Lowery

I studied systematic theology at Wheaton College Graduate School, studying under Daniel Treier and writing my dissertation on ecclesiological models in Africa. I grew up in East Africa, and am happy to have returned at long last!
This entry was posted in Book reviews, Integration and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Review: Jack Barentsen, “Emerging Leadership in the Pauline Mission: A Social Identity Perspective on Local Leadership Development in Corinth and Ephesus”

  1. Hi Stephanie, Just gratefully read your review of my dissertation. Thanks. Make me wonder what you (or others at Wheaton) are working on, perhaps along these lines?

    • Jack,

      Hi! Ah, yes, what are we up to at Wheaton? Good question! Wheaton’s PhD program is integrative in nature, which helps explain my work a bit. I’m a systematic theologian studying African ecclesiological models, and particularly the importance of unity/community and finding one’s primary identity in the Body of Christ. I also weave into that mix some African fiction. Anyway, one of the biblical texts I appeal to is Gal 3:26-29, hence my strong interest in your book. That book was one of the best works on Paul I’ve read in the last 4-5 years.

      I’d love to dialogue further about your book. Do you mind if I e-mail you?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s